Bitcoin (BTC) vs SPY, GLD: 122% Surge Last Year, Flat This Year—Two-Year +50% Average, Says Eric Balchunas
According to Eric Balchunas, BTC gained 122% last year—about 5x SPY and GLD—and he says this year’s flat performance simply mean-reverts the two-year average to roughly +50% (source: Eric Balchunas on X, Nov 15, 2025). For traders, Balchunas’s framing signals compressed near-term alpha versus equities and gold, suggesting a neutral or range-focused posture in BTC relative strength monitoring (source: Eric Balchunas on X, Nov 15, 2025).
SourceAnalysis
In the ever-volatile world of cryptocurrency trading, Bitcoin (BTC) has once again sparked discussions among investors and analysts, particularly regarding its performance relative to traditional assets like the S&P 500 ETF (SPY) and gold ETF (GLD). According to financial analyst Eric Balchunas, Bitcoin enthusiasts were quick to celebrate last year's impressive 122% surge, which outpaced SPY and GLD by a factor of five. This excess return was embraced without complaints about deviations from historical norms, yet this year's lackluster performance has drawn scrutiny. Balchunas points out that averaging out to a 50% gain over the period still positions BTC holders as fortunate, urging a balanced perspective amid market fluctuations.
Bitcoin's Historical Performance and Market Correlations
Diving deeper into trading insights, Bitcoin's 122% rally in the previous year highlighted its potential for outsized gains compared to risk assets. Traders often monitor BTC's correlation with SPY, which tracks the broader stock market, to gauge risk-on sentiment. Last year's outperformance suggested a decoupling where BTC acted as a leveraged play on market optimism, drawing institutional flows and boosting trading volumes across pairs like BTC/USD and BTC/ETH. However, this year's flat performance, as noted by Balchunas on November 15, 2025, brings the two-year average to around 50%, aligning more closely with long-term historical averages for high-volatility assets. This normalization could signal maturing market dynamics, where BTC's beta to equities stabilizes, offering traders opportunities in hedging strategies. For instance, if SPY experiences upward momentum, BTC might follow suit, but current sentiment indicates caution, with support levels around $60,000 potentially tested if selling pressure increases.
Trading Opportunities Amid Volatility
From a trading standpoint, this perspective encourages focusing on relative value trades. Bitcoin's excess returns last year amplified portfolios, but the 'nothing' this year underscores the importance of diversification. On-chain metrics, such as increased Bitcoin accumulation by long-term holders during dips, suggest underlying strength despite surface-level stagnation. Traders might look at resistance levels near $70,000, where breakout potential could emerge if positive catalysts like regulatory clarity or ETF inflows materialize. Correlations with GLD also merit attention; while gold serves as an inflation hedge, BTC's narrative as digital gold positions it for similar roles, potentially leading to arbitrage opportunities in BTC/GLD pairs. Institutional investors, tracking these trends, have shown resilience, with average annual returns averaging 50% still outperforming many traditional assets over multi-year horizons.
Shifting to broader market implications, this analysis ties into stock market correlations, where BTC often mirrors Nasdaq movements due to tech-heavy influences. If SPY rallies on economic data, BTC could see sympathetic gains, creating cross-market trading setups. Conversely, risk-off environments might pressure BTC more than GLD, highlighting its higher volatility. Traders should monitor trading volumes, which spiked during last year's run-up, as indicators of momentum. Without real-time data, sentiment leans neutral, but historical patterns suggest averaging 50% returns remains attractive for long-term holders. Peaceful market navigation, as Balchunas advocates, involves embracing the averages rather than chasing extremes, potentially leading to more sustainable trading strategies.
Ultimately, this discourse from Eric Balchunas serves as a reminder for cryptocurrency traders to maintain perspective. While last year's double-dip gains were exhilarating, this year's breather averages out positively. For those eyeing entry points, current levels might offer value, especially if on-chain activity like rising active addresses signals revival. Integrating these insights with stock market trends, such as SPY's performance, can uncover hedged positions or leveraged trades. As the crypto market evolves, focusing on these correlations enhances decision-making, potentially turning average returns into compounded success over time.
Eric Balchunas
@EricBalchunasBloomberg's Senior ETF Analyst and acclaimed author, co-hosting Trillions & ETF IQ while bringing deep institutional investment insights.