Dubai vs GIFT City: Who Wins the Crypto Sandbox Race?
Khushi V Rangdhol Sep 04, 2025 23:54
In 2025, Dubai leads with a clear crypto regulatory framework for businesses, while GIFT City focuses on institutional tokenization within a conservative policy. Different models serve distinct markets.
Dubai and GIFT City are racing toward the same horizon—digital-asset finance—but they’re running on different tracks. Dubai has built a licence-led virtual assets regime aimed at letting crypto businesses operate at scale today. GIFT City has built a ring-fenced financial innovation zone that welcomes tokenisation of traditional assets while keeping retail crypto trading at arm’s length. In 2025, those choices matter more than the marketing slogans.
Two models, two destinies
Dubai’s Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (VARA) publishes activity-specific rulebooks—exchange, brokerage, custody, lending/borrowing, issuance, investment management, transfer/settlement, advisory—and issues production licences. The early “MVP” phase has largely given way to full market authorisations, which means firms can graduate from pilot to live business on clear terms. The message is pragmatic: bring your crypto business, but do it under rules.
GIFT City, regulated by the International Financial Services Centres Authority (IFSCA), operates within a tightly defined jurisdiction. Its flagship tools are a regulatory sandbox and an innovation sandbox that let institutions test tokenised versions of regulated instruments—securities, funds, commodities, credit—using real money but under controlled limits. Crypto coins and retail trading remain out of scope. The emphasis is plumbing, not speculation: market infrastructure, compliance controls, and capital-market products that happen to live on chain.
Speed, certainty, and audience
For companies that need to serve clients now—exchanges, broker-dealers, custodians, lenders—Dubai offers speed to market and regulatory certainty. Licences are granted for specific activities; marketing and risk disclosures are prescribed; and there’s a public register of authorised firms. The environment suits operators who want to run regional or global books under a recognisable VASP framework, with the wider UAE ecosystem (SCA, ADGM, DIFC) nearby.
GIFT City’s value proposition is different. If you’re a bank, fund house, broker or fintech designing real-world asset (RWA) tokenisation—a fund share class on chain, a structured note with programmable settlement, bullion receipts represented as tokens—GIFT provides close regulator access, phased approvals, and integration with India’s evolving capital-markets reforms (direct listings, global access programmes). It prioritises institutional use-cases over retail crypto exposure.
National policy context
Dubai’s stance aligns with the UAE’s broader ambition to be a digital-asset hub: permissive of activity, strict on licensing and risk controls. India’s national policy remains cautious toward crypto as a financial asset—taxed heavily, policed tightly—while being enthusiastic about on-chain finance that fits existing law (tokenised securities, CBDC pilots, account-to-account real-time rails). GIFT City reflects that balance: innovate inside the perimeter; avoid creating parallel, retail crypto markets.
What “winning” looks like in 2025
If success is measured by live, licensed crypto businesses, Dubai is ahead. It has a complete rulebook, real operators in production, and a regulator that iterates in public.
If success is measured by institutional tokenisation within a conservative policy perimeter, GIFT City is the right tool for the job. It is building compliant rails for traditional finance to move on chain—less flashy than a crypto exchange launch, but potentially deeper in the long run if tokenised markets scale.
Choosing a home
- A firm planning an exchange, brokerage, custody stack, lending desk, or a compliant token issuance with near-term retail or professional clients will find Dubai the more immediately operable venue.
- A firm designing tokenised funds, securities or credit for institutional investors—especially those integrated with India’s market infrastructure—will find GIFT City the more strategically aligned venue.
Different finish lines, different winners. Dubai is staking its claim as a global marketplace for virtual assets; GIFT City is laying regulated foundations for traditional finance to go on chain. The smarter question for founders and institutions isn’t “who wins?” but “which rulebook matches my product—and my time horizon?”
Image source: Shutterstock
.jpg)