3 Extreme Crypto Signals: Fear and Greed Index Record Low, Short-Term Holder PnL Most Negative, RSI at LUNA/COVID/FTX Lows
According to @CryptoMichNL, the crypto fear and greed index just hit its lowest reading on record, signaling extreme risk-off sentiment at current prices, source: @CryptoMichNL on X, Nov 23, 2025. According to @CryptoMichNL, short-term holder supply PnL is the most negative ever, highlighting acute realized loss pressure among recent buyers, source: @CryptoMichNL on X, Nov 23, 2025. According to @CryptoMichNL, RSI has dropped to levels last seen during the LUNA, COVID, and FTX market lows, indicating historically oversold momentum, source: @CryptoMichNL on X, Nov 23, 2025. According to @CryptoMichNL, despite these extremes many participants still want to buy lower, reflecting persistent bearish bias even at current levels, source: @CryptoMichNL on X, Nov 23, 2025.
SourceAnalysis
The cryptocurrency market is currently experiencing unprecedented levels of fear, as highlighted by prominent analyst Michaël van de Poppe. In a recent statement, he pointed out that the fear and greed index for crypto has reached its lowest point ever, signaling extreme pessimism among investors. This metric, which gauges market sentiment on a scale from 0 to 100, dipping to historic lows suggests that panic selling could be at its peak, often a contrarian indicator for potential rebounds. Van de Poppe also noted that the short-term holder supply profit and loss (PNL) is the heaviest ever, meaning many recent buyers are underwater on their positions, adding to the downward pressure. Furthermore, RSI levels across major cryptocurrencies are mirroring those seen during the lows of the LUNA collapse, the COVID-19 market crash, and the FTX debacle, periods that marked significant bottoms before recoveries. Despite these signals, many traders are holding out for even lower prices to buy in, a strategy that could backfire if the market turns bullish sooner than expected.
Crypto Market Sentiment Hits Rock Bottom: Analyzing the Fear and Greed Index
Diving deeper into the fear and greed index, this tool aggregates data from volatility, market momentum, social media, surveys, dominance, and trends to provide a snapshot of investor psychology. When it plunges to extreme fear territories, as it has now, historical patterns show it's often a buying opportunity for long-term holders. For instance, during the FTX collapse in late 2022, the index hit similar lows, and Bitcoin (BTC) bottomed around $15,000 before surging over 150% in the following year. Today, with BTC trading around recent support levels, this extreme fear could indicate capitulation. Traders should watch for volume spikes on exchanges like Binance, where BTC/USDT pairs often see billions in daily turnover. If on-chain metrics, such as increased whale accumulation or rising stablecoin inflows, start appearing, it might signal the end of the downtrend. However, the irony lies in retail investors' reluctance; van de Poppe's 'good luck' quip underscores the risk of missing the bottom while chasing lower entries. For those considering positions, focusing on key support zones—BTC at $50,000 or ETH at $2,000—could offer high-reward setups if sentiment shifts.
RSI Levels and Historical Comparisons: Trading Opportunities in Oversold Conditions
The Relative Strength Index (RSI), a momentum oscillator, is flashing oversold signals comparable to past crypto winters. On the daily chart, BTC's RSI is hovering around 30, a level that preceded rallies during the LUNA crash in May 2022, when Terra's ecosystem imploded, dragging the market down. Similarly, the COVID crash in March 2020 saw RSI dip to 20, followed by a massive bull run. The FTX fallout in November 2022 pushed RSI to similar depths, with BTC recovering from $16,000 to over $60,000. Currently, without real-time data specifying exact prices, traders can monitor live charts for divergences—where price makes lower lows but RSI forms higher lows, hinting at reversal. Short-term holders' heavy PNL losses, as mentioned, imply potential forced selling, but this exhaustion often clears the path for fresh capital. Institutional flows, tracked via tools like Glassnode, show mixed signals; while some funds are derisking, others like BlackRock's ETF inflows suggest underlying demand. For altcoins like ETH, SOL, or ADA, pairing RSI with moving averages (e.g., 50-day SMA) could identify breakout points. Volume analysis is crucial—look for increasing buy volumes on dips, which might confirm a bottom formation around these historic parallels.
From a broader trading perspective, this environment presents cross-market opportunities, especially with correlations to stock indices like the S&P 500. If equities rebound amid easing inflation, crypto could follow suit, amplifying gains in BTC and ETH. However, risks remain, including regulatory pressures or macroeconomic headwinds. Van de Poppe's observation encourages contrarian thinking: while the crowd fears further drops, savvy traders might accumulate at these prices, targeting resistance levels like BTC's $60,000 mark for potential 20-30% upside. On-chain data supports this, with metrics like mean coin age rising, indicating hodling behavior. For those eyeing leveraged trades, options on platforms like Deribit show elevated implied volatility, offering premium-selling strategies in oversold conditions. Ultimately, patience is key; historical precedents suggest that buying during extreme fear has rewarded investors handsomely, but always pair sentiment with technical confirmation. As the market navigates these lows, staying informed on indicators like the fear and greed index could be the edge needed for profitable trades.
Broader Implications for Crypto Trading Strategies
Integrating this sentiment data into trading strategies, investors should consider dollar-cost averaging (DCA) into blue-chip cryptos like BTC and ETH during these dips, as past cycles show recoveries often exceed 100% from bottoms. The heavy short-term holder losses could lead to a supply squeeze if prices stabilize, pushing altcoins higher. Keep an eye on trading volumes across pairs like ETH/BTC, which might signal relative strength. If AI-driven analytics tools predict sentiment shifts based on social media trends, it could provide early entry signals. In summary, while the desire to buy lower persists, the data points to a potential inflection point, urging traders to act decisively rather than wait indefinitely.
Michaël van de Poppe
@CryptoMichNLMacro-Economics, Value Based Investing & Trading || Crypto & Bitcoin Enthusiast